Donald Trump. Pic: Jim Watson/AFP
Donald Trump. Pic: Jim Watson/AFP

WINNER TAKES ALL: US faces ‘complete and utter meltdown’

AMERICA'S midterm elections are just hours away, and the media is saturated with analysis of what they will mean for Donald Trump.

The short version? If the midterms go badly for him, and Mr Trump's party loses control of the House of Representatives, he will be left in a deeply uncomfortable position, unable to pass legislation without help from his political opponents.

But what if that doesn't happen? What if Mr Trump's Republicans do surprisingly well, and the Democrats fall short of taking back the House?

The Daily Beast has examined that "unthinkable" scenario in some depth. It reports that failure in the midterms could plunge the Democrats into an "utter and complete psychological meltdown".

"After all this work, all these volunteers, it would be absolutely shattering," Democratic strategist Paul Begala told the website.

"I can't even contemplate it, it would be so indescribable," said former Congressman Steve Israel.

There is no contingency plan. No attempt to prepare for the potential disaster. Mr Trump's enemies are gambling everything on winning.


The Democrats need to take 23 seats from the Republicans to win control of the House, and if the polls are any guide, they should succeed.

The predictive model at FiveThirtyEight currently projects an 88 per cent chance of them winning the seats required.

A late CNN poll shows the Democrats leading a generic ballot 55-42 thanks to a surge in support from women, independents and minority voters.

Mr Trump doesn't think much of that poll.

And there is no guarantee the polls are correct. It all depends on how accurately they have predicted voter turnout.

"Because America has voluntary voting, not like Australia's compulsory voting, a lot more of it involves convincing your side to turn out and vote, rather than convincing undecided voters in the centre to support you," Dr Shaun Ratcliff from the US Studies Centre told

It makes these midterm elections extremely hard to predict.
Donald Trump is an extraordinarily polarising person. He energises elements of the Republican base, who love him, and the Democrats, who hate him, at the same time.

That is reflected in the early vote totals for these midterms, which are high. Very high. In several states, there have been more early votes this year than there were total votes last time, in 2014.

"Democratic voters are usually less likely to turn out," Dr Ratcliff said.

"They're generally lower income, younger or minority voters, and are often people with fewer resources who can't afford to go out on Tuesday to vote."

With that in mind, unusually high voter turnout could be a good sign for them.

But winning the popular vote will not necessarily be enough - just ask Hillary Clinton, who beat Mr Trump by almost three million votes but still lost the 2016 election.

Dr Ratcliff said the Democrats would need a majority of "at least 6 per cent".

What if their nightmare comes true again? What if all the pollsters and pundits have missed a surge of silent Trump supporters?


The Democrats went through a mild identity crisis in 2016, as Ms Clinton struggled to hold off a surprisingly stubborn challenge from left-wing Senator Bernie Sanders in the fight for the party's presidential nomination.

Mr Sanders offered a less restrained version of progressivism, which resonated with millions of Democratic voters. In the wake of Ms Clinton's defeat to Mr Trump, some wondered whether he could have won in her place.

Should Democrats fail tomorrow, the argument about what kind of progressive party they should be will start again.

When he spoke to Four Corners in September, Mr Trump's former top political adviser Steve Bannon warned there would be "civil war" in the party.

"If they lose this November, the civil war inside the Democratic Party is going to consume them for years and is going to make Donald Trump's re-election in 2020 a forgone conclusion," he said.

"The grassroots of the Democratic left are doing exactly what the Tea Party movement did in 2010."

Barack Obama was president in 2010, and Republican voters were frustrated by their party's inability to oppose his agenda effectively. The Tea Party movement grew as a response to that, propelling Republicans to a crushing victory in the midterms that year.

The Democrats lost 63 House seats and six Senate seats in a historic wipe-out, which left Washington hopelessly gridlocked for the remaining six years of Mr Obama's presidency.

Democrats are acutely aware of the risks they are facing this time around.

"A failure to take the House would be near apocalyptic for the country," Democratic Congressman Jim Hines told Esquire.

Former Clinton and Obama official Kenneth Baer said they "would have an internal battle at a scale not seen since after the 1988 defeat of Michael Dukakis," when Republican presidential candidate George H.W. Bush won 40 out of 50 states.

"In one corner would be the class warfare Sanders wing, and in another would be the intersectional, social issues left, and in a third would be the establishment Liberals," Mr Baer said.

Compounding that problem would be the lack of a clear leader as the Democrats looked ahead to the 2020 election.

Mr Obama has been their most effective voice in this midterm campaign, but he has already served two terms as president. If Mr Trump runs for re-election, someone else will have to lead the charge against him.

"Obama's got a unique combination of things, and that is going to be quite hard to replicate," Professor Brendon O'Connor told

"He is kind of a towering figure in the party. No one, as we saw with Hillary Clinton, has got the same appeal to the coalition that he put together."

Some of the contenders for Mr Obama's mantle, such as Massachusetts Senator Elizabeth Warren and Mr Sanders, are busy quietly defending their own seats at the moment.

Others, like former Massachusetts governor Deval Patrick, California Senator Kamala Harris and former vice president Joe Biden, have been a little more active.

If the party descends into chaos, one of them will have to emerge as its new leader.

‘Big, big news’: Cop-killer’s chilling warning

Premium Content ‘Big, big news’: Cop-killer’s chilling warning

A day later, he would shoot and kill Senior Constable Brett Forte

Tourism to pay dearly for botched vaccine rollout

Premium Content Tourism to pay dearly for botched vaccine rollout

Queensland’s tourism sector will have to scrap revival plans

SUCCESS: Roma’s tourism body gifts $37k mini train to council

Premium Content SUCCESS: Roma’s tourism body gifts $37k mini train to...

‘For the betterment of the region’: Roma Commerce and Tourism raised over $37,000...